Home

Why did Dumbledore have to die

Why did Dumbledore have to die..? He had to die for so many reasons and all to motivate Harry in one way or another. He had to die so Harry would finally realize he had to finish Voldemort. Dumbledore had to die so Harry would realize the truth behind what Dumbledore had told him Shortly thereafter, Albus, who had been exchanging owls with the famous researcher as far back when he had been a student at Hogwarts, travelled to France an The actual Reason Dumbledore's death Was changed In The Movie Albus Dumbledore passed away during the battle of the Astronomy Tower (also recognized as the battle of the Lightning-Struck Tower) Three reasons, really: firstly, as part of Harry's transition from boyhood to full blown adult wizardry, the death of Dumbledore represents the point at which Harry is fully exposed to the fight. First off, Dumbledore was already dying from a downright horrifying curse. Killing him with the Killing Curse would have been merciful. Second, he was hoping to save Malfoy from going down the road to irredeemable evil. If Malfoy had managed to kill Dumbledore of his own free will, then he'd be just as bad as any other Death Eater

An ordinary man should have died at once, but Dumbledore with the help of snape contained the effect of curse to just one hand for the time being and that is why his one hand was seen almost black in the movies.They could only slow down. Dumbledore was on the hunt for horcruxes, and he did found one on his own Why did Dumbledore have to die? Wiki User. ∙ 2008-12-20 20:03:54. Quiz mode. See Answer. Best Answer. Copy. He got poisoned by one of Voldemort's Horcruxes so being weird he asked Snape to kill. Dumbledore knew Harry was going to have to die eventually. Sure, he knew he might be able to bounce back from it because of the Horcrux but ultimately, it was a totally untested theory because it had never been done before. Even then, he was still absolutely willing to bring Harry up and let him go and die without even telling him why. What? Over the course of seven books and eight films, Harry Potter's adventures packed many twists and turns, but few shocked fans as much as Albus Dumbledore's d Why Did Dumbledore Have To Die In Harry Potter As he was about to die by a cursed ring, Dumbledore planned his own death with Severus Snape. Per the plan, Dumbledore was killed by Snape during the Battle of the Astronomy Tower . Though he was no longer alive at the time, it was through Dumbledore's manipulations that Voldemort was ultimately defeated, and lasting peace finally restored to the wizarding world

Why did Dumbledore have to die in Harry Potter? - Quor

Dumbledore have to die to fit the purposes : To end the cycle of killing of the elder wand, so if he died willingly through sanpe's hand the elder wand would become master. Continue Reading. Because before his death he was already near to his death due to the curse of Marvolo Gant's ring Someone please help me out and explain this one. Why didn't Dumbledore save himself in Harry Potter by using Fawkes? Was it not possible? Or did Dumbledore need to die? Ok so if you didn't know about Dumbledore dying in Harry Potter that is on you. Both the books and the movies have been out long enough for you to have either read them, or seen them, by now It seems that to Dumbledore, defeating Voldemort could only happen in one way: by having Voldemort die. The entire quest to find and destroy the horcruxes took place only to achieve this objective. Harry even was willing to sacrifice himself in order to bring Voldemort closer to death. Why did Dumbledore assume this was the only option, though

Why Did Dumbledore Have To Die - Harry Potter Fans Clu

In addition to the many reasons that Dumbledore values life and does not just let people die, a part of Dumbledore's plan was to have Harry hunt down the Horcruxes so that others did not have to risk their lives. He knew that Harry had to die but sending him to hunt Horcruxes saved others So yes, Dumbledore did indeed ask Snape to kill him to spare Draco the Dark Lord's wrath or a maimed soul because of Draco's very own attempts to kill Dumbledore. But it wasn't he assumed the Dark Lord'd death Draco because that the wand. However, though Dumbledore go ask Snape to kill him, the wasn't because he believed that the Dark Lord would. So Why Did Snape Killed Dumbledore. Snape killed Dumbledore because he asked him to do so. Dumbledore had a feeling that Voldemort had instructed Malfoy to kill him but wanted to die his way. The Killing Of Dumbledore By Snape. There were several speculations on the rationale behind the killing of Dumbledore by Snape

Why Did Dumbledore Have To Die In A Way That Portrays Him

He also may have lied because he also says that he has been pretending to be Dumbledore's pet and that though he did not return straight to the Dark Lord's side as soon as he felt the dark mark burn on his arm he stayed at Hogwarts and returned 2 hours later to keep his cover. Please comment if you have a veiw on this issue Dumbledore's death is revealed to have been a result of Snape, who acted as a double spy while blaming himself for the death of Lily Potter. The series and Half Blood Prince give us plenty of opportunities to question Snape s loyalties. From Snape s accounts about Voldemort and the Death Eaters, Dumbledore was able to organize his counterattack

Why, oh why, did Dumbledore have to die? Notes and

Albus Dumbledore is one of the most important characters in the Harry Potter series. Dumbledore is the greatest wizard of the age and his presence as headmaster of Hogwarts helped to both inspire and protect Harry against the Dark Lord until the headmaster's heartbreaking death in the sixth installment of the franchise. Despite Dumbledore's strong presence across the books and the movies (even. In Deathly Hallows 2, we learn that Dumbledore got cursed by the ring that was a Horcrux from HBP and Snape was able to contain the curse to Dumbledore's hand, which was why it was dead looking. Snape also tells him that he has about a year left to live. We also find out that Dumbledore knew of Voldermort's plan to have Draco kill him (Dumbledore) We have a few theories on how this would fit in the established canon: 1. This could be a lie told by Grindelwald to convince Credence to go after Albus Dumbledore - after all, we know Gellert Grindelwald is seductive and manipulative. He could be lying to Credence Barone, as he did before (in the form of Percival Graves) Home / Fashion / why did dumbledore tell snape harry had to die . why did dumbledore tell snape harry had to die. By on 2 de julio de 2021 0. Dumbledore stood up to greet Trelawney, therefore making him the first of the 13 to get up from dinner. Sure, it could be a coincidence, or it could have been a nod about Dumbledore's fate from J.K. Rowling. Clever! Dumbledore, at one point, possessed all three Deathly Hallow

Why, then, would Grindelwald talk about using Credence to kill Dumbledore at the risk of his destruction? One possible explanation is that Grindelwald believes that Dumbledore, tormented by Ariana's death, won't be able to bring himself to destroy Credence. Another question fans have asked is, How does Nagini turn bad How many men and women have you watched die? 24. Not only did Dumbledore refuse to acknowledge the horror of what he had planned for Harry, he insinuated that Snape had no right to feel affronted First and foremost, yes, Dumbledore did ask Snape to kill him, and this was to save Draco Malfoy from having to carry out the sinister task. This was vital because should Malfoy have killed Dumbledore, it would have corrupted Malfoy's soul and turned him dark. In Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Chapter 33, you can read; All the same. Albus Percival Wulfric Brian Dumbledore is a fictional character in J. K. Rowling's Harry Potter series. For most of the series, he is the headmaster of the wizarding school Hogwarts.As part of his backstory, it is revealed that he is the founder and leader of the Order of the Phoenix, an organisation dedicated to fighting Lord Voldemort, the main antagonist of the series Why did Dumbledore let himself die? He was dying because of the curse on his hand. He had less than a year to live as of the summer before HBP started. So he decided to have Snape kill him, rather than Draco, to preserve Draco's soul, and also to solidify Snape's role as double-agent

Dumbledore asked snape to kill him. Dumbledore had put on a ring that was one of Voldemorts horcruxes. His hand was badly burned and it was goin to kill him. Dumbledore asked Snape to kill him because : 1. Dumbledore was going to die anyways. 2. Snape could convince the Death Eaters and Voldemort that he was on their side 428. Location: Egypt. Jun 26, 2006 #2. I think he knew he was going to die, that does not mean that he knew about snapes promise to help draco but he might have been dying from the damage he got to his hand from destroying the horcrux, that could be why he was so willing to drink the liquid that protected the fake horcrux. For with Dumbledore's death came revelations of a murky past; stories of Dark Arts and a mysterious sister. As revealed by his brother Aberforth, Dumbledore used to be a different man. He was young, brilliant and frustrated; his talents were held back by the responsibility of caring for his sister Ariana, who was left traumatised after a Muggle attack This is why when Harry got hit by the Killing curse he did end up in J. K. Rowling's version of heaven he wasn't actually dead. After the conversation with professor Dumbledore, he got the chance to either stay with him or return to the real world. Why did Dumbledore give Harry the Resurrection Stone

When Dumbledore asked Harry why he did not die, Harry replied that Voldemort took his blood. Voldemort could not touch Harry due to the protection Lily gave him. In the first year, Voldemort could not touch harry. So, we can see in Harry Potter and the Goblet of fire that Peter used Harry's blood to for Voldemort's return Why did Dumbledore have James' invisibility cloak at the time of James' death, given that Dumbledore could make himself invisible without a cloak? Prior to posting this I had a quick look on-line, and realised that some fans have been speculating about this question Had Snape not intervened with a counter-curse, Dumbledore would have died much more quickly. Why did Snape and Lily have the same Patronus? The reason Severus Snape has the same patronus as Lily's is because he was deeply in love with her and the grief and guilt he felt after her death may have cause his patronus to change into a doe, or it already was a doe depending on when he first cast the. Originally Answered: Why did Dumbledore sacrifice himself? He was in pain, from the curse he had due to breaking Marvolo Gaunt's ring. He probably wanted to die on his own terms. He wanted to make it appear such that Snape was playing for Voldemort's team, so that Voldemort would trust him with absolutely anything

Albus Dumbledore's Father Died In Azkaban. As mentioned, Ariana experienced a childhood trauma that may have turned her into an Obscurial. That trauma came at the result of the assault of a gang. Knowing Harry, no matter how close he was to Dumbledore, he could not have come up with a more Dumbledore answer. Harry did die, enter limbo, and had the option to truly die and let his soul pass on to the land of the living, but he chose the noble decision to return and fight Why did they change the Dumbledore actor? Harris was determined to portray Dumbledore again in Prisoner of Azkaban (2004), despite having been diagnosed with Hodgkin's lymphoma, and asked David Heyman not to recast the role. Michael Gambon was cast as Harris' replacement four months after Harris' death The full title of this post is Why did Albus Dumbledore leave baby Harry Potter on the doorstep of the Dursleys' house? In Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone, book 1 of the HP series by J.K. Rowling, we found out that Headmaster Dumbledore decided to leave baby Harry on the doorstep of his relatives' hous Here goes, Harry did not die for a number of reasons, firstly, Voldemort used Harry's blood to rebuild his body, so now you have both Harry and Voldemort with the protection that Harry's mum created when she sacrificed herself, meaning that they could not kill each other if they defended themselves, Harry went to the forest with the full intention of dying, he wasn't going to defend himself.

Why did Dumbledore have to die? : harrypotte

Aug 24, 2005. #1. Was there more to Malfoy's task from Voldermort than killing Dumbledore? He worked and worked to ensure the Death Eaters could get into the castle, yet when they did get in, none of them were allowed to kill Dumbledore, the one man kept saying that it was for Draco to do, until Snape got there, and Snape just did it Voldemort dies because all 7 Horcruxes are destroyed. Harry became one of them, when Voldemort attempts to kill Harry on the night Lily and James Potter die. When Harry got the scar he also got powers. A little piece of Voldemort lived inside of him. That's why Harry can speak Parseltongue and can see Voldemort's thoughts Years have passed, though, and in our processing of these deaths, we finally have had some time to sit back and think about why Hedwig had to die. We all know, of course, the circumstances of. Why did Dumbledore have James' invisibility cloak at the time of James' death, given that Dumbledore could make himself invisible without a cloak? Prior to posting this I had a quick look on-line, and realised that some fans have been speculating about this question. However, nobody has ever asked me about it, and they really should have done

Why Did Voldemort Kill Harry Potter’s Parents? – Fiction

Why did Harry Potter break the Elder Wand? Harry broke the Elder Wand because he knows that all its past owners, including Antioch Peverell (its first owner), had used it for boasting and power. And like Dumbledore, Harry tried to protect himself and others from too much power. So, in order to do this, he must destroy the source of the power. Why did Cedric Diggory have to die? Cedric had to die simply because he was an inconvenience to Voldemort. Voldemort set up a very direct plan to be reborn, and he needed Harry. Cedric was not supposed to come along, so like Voldemort always does, he just got rid of him. Cedric had to die simply because he was an inconvenience to Voldemort

Why did Dumbledore die? - Wizarding World Wonders 18

  1. Did Dumbledore get the Elder Wand from Grindelwald? As fans know, Dumbledore won the Elder Wand off Gellert Grindelwald when they dueled in 1945, and Dumbledore maintained control of the Elder Wand until his death. Eventually the Elder Wand came into Harry Potter's possession, and he decided to snap it in two and throw it away
  2. Why did Cedric Diggory have to die? For the simple answer: Cedric had to die simply because he was an inconvenience to Voldemort. Voldemort set up a very direct plan to be reborn, and he needed Harry. Cedric was not supposed to come along, so like Voldemort always does, he just got rid of him
  3. Dumbledore also knew about the prophecy that Professor Trelawney foretold long before Harry ever came to Hogwarts. He knew that in order to kill Voldemort, Harry likely had to die as well. From the very first time Harry asked questions about his scar until Sirius' death, Dumbledore concealed all of this crucial information
  4. d. Even though he had a Pensieve where he could have put memories. 2
  5. Ron now understood why Dumbledore had helped him with the Squibs when no one else would. Ron understood why Dumbledore had let Remus Lupin attend Hogwarts, and then later, even hired him to teach. Ron finally understood why Dumbledore was such a constant advocate for the power of 'Love'
  6. Why did Snape have to kill Dumbledore? Half-blood prince And the final volume of the series, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Here are some of the reasons why Dumbledore had to die at this point in the saga and why it had to be Snape to chant the Killing Curse

Question about Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince: WHY DID DUMBLEDORE HAVE TO DIE??

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News and Media Limited 201 via Movies - We Got This Covered https://ift.tt/3EIJBZ Because J.K. Rowling may have confirmed that Dumbledore is indeed death. So the theory connects to the Tale of Three Brothers story that was told in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. In the story, three brothers come across a river that is too dangerous to cross. They cast a spell to form a bridge and cross the river safely

Using Theory Garden, we analyze the driving forces in Harry Potter and the Half-blood Prince in order to discover if Dumbledore really had to die in order fo.. Why did Dumbledore think Voldemort have to die? I GET IT. Like, I get why Voldemort had to die. I get it, it's for the greater good and all but Harry Potter author, J.K. Rowling has revealed her 'favourite' fan theory about everyone's favourite headteacher, professor Dumbledore.. Seventeen years since the first film was released, people really can't get enough of the wizarding world of Harry Potter. Fans and theorists to this day spend time cooking up new theories

00:00 - Why did Dumbledore wait for Harry to die?00:32 - Did Harry really talk to Dumbledore when he died?01:03 - Why did Snape and Lily have the same Patron.. Harry did not die because Rowling wanted to make an example of Harry, equating him to war heroes who survive and help rebuild societies. Once it was decided that Harry had to come out alive, it was only a matter of sorting out horcrux technicalities. There were multiple reasons why Harry did not die when hit with the AK curse while he should have Why did snape kill Dumbledore? Dumbledore was fatally wounded by attempting to use Marvolo's ring, which held a powerful curse and blackened his arm. Snape managed to postpone Dumbledore's death with magic and his potions, but for no more than one year. Dumbledore asked Snape to kill him to: Save Draco Malfoy Dumbledore seems to know everything Harry and Ron did/are about to do. Presumably, an older Ron would have used a time-turner to go back and be Dumbledore

Why did Dumbledore have to die? - Answer

Dumbledore might not have known whether the Wand would transfer to Snape or whether its power would die with him. In fact, the result may have depended on Snape's own loyalties. Dumbledore said to Snape, You alone know whether it will harm your soul to help an old man avoid pain and humiliation (DH 683) It's all very Bette vs. Joan—though the parallels would be starker if McKellen had embraced a pettier nature and gone on to play Dumbledore after all. (Joan would have.) Michael Gambon, of. So it's entirely possible that Grindelwald did tell Dumbledore how Ariana died, At the very least, it's the only known reason why Dumbledore was keeping his distance from Grindelwald JKR at Edinburgh Book Festival wrote:The other question that I am surprised no one has asked me since Phoenix came out - I thought that people would-is why Dumbledore did not kill or try to kill Voldemort in the scene in the ministry. I know that I am giving a lot away to people who have not read the book. Although Dumbledore gives a kind of reason to Voldemort, it is not the real reason.

Did Dumbledore know that Sirius Black was innocent? - Quora

Reasons Why We Hate Dumbledore - TheThing

Dumbledore knew both sides of this feud, but did nothing to help Harry and Snape get over their issues with each other. If Snape didn't give Harry some of his memories in his final moments, Harry never would have known about Snape and Lily's connection or Snape's years of trying to honor Lily by protecting Harry behind the scenes Re: Why did Dumbledore have James' invisibility cloak at the time of James' death? There is one glaringly obvious problem to the Snape was at GH theory, and that is: Snape would have KNOWN that Peter Pettigrew was secret keeper and that Peter Pettigrew blew up the street full of muggles; and that kind of thing isn't something he'd keep from Dumbledore, so Dumbledore would've known all that. But did Dumbledore have to leave a baby on a doorstep? Not telling Harry that he was always meant to die is one thing, but Dumbledore ignored him for all of The Order of the Phoenix Dumbledore did not plan for Harry to die. Unless you took this too literally. I have spied for you and lied for you, put myself in mortal danger for you. Everything was supposed to be to keep Lily Potter's son safe. Now you tell me you have been raising him like a pig for slaughter

Why Did Dumbledore Have To Die In Harry Potter

  1. Longtime fans of the series have been aware of Albus Dumbledore's friendship with Gellert Grindelwald since Harry Potter And The Deathly Hallows was published in 2007, the same year author J.K.
  2. istrative Systems and Service Delivery Concerns for New York State's Individuals with Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities; Position Papers. Managed Care Position Paper(s) Concerns about CAS (Coordinated Assessment System) - 11/15/17; CCO/HHs - Memorandum of Concern -7/1
  3. Dumbledore and Harry's Horcrux: When did he know? October 14, 2019—This week's supplement to the podcast episode (about Horcruxes check it out if you haven't already) will be a little different. I've decided to answer a single question dancing around the Harry Potter fandom about everyone's favorite Horcrux
  4. ator? A re
  5. Why did Snape kill Dumbledore? Snape had to kill Dumbledore. Firstly, because it was an act of mercy for Dumbledore, as he was already dying, first from the curse he received when he put on the Gaunt ring, and second when he drank the potion from the cave with the locket horcrux. That's what Dumbledore means when he says Severus
  6. Dumbledore did not tell Harry about Voldemort's Horcruxes until he, Dumbledore, was on the brink of death due the wasting curse placed on Marvolo Gaunt's ring. He said my blood would make him stronger than if he'd used someone else's, Harry told Dumbledore

Although Dumbledore's name never surfaced, it was not an expert sleuth to determine who they wanted McKellen to play with. McKellen turned down the part for some surprising reason. This was due to her history with Harris, who had been critical of her acting career in the past. When he died, he played the magician Dumbledore 1: Dumbledore trusted Snape because he knew how snape felt about Lily, and his hatred for Voldemort after what he did to her. He also had Snape working as a sort of double agent feeding Voldemort wrong information while gathering helpful information for Dumbledore. Snape killed dumbledore because he was told to do so by dumbledore himself

When he finally understood why, he knew he had to kill the true owner of the Wand. He had to kill Severus. However, his experience with wands had taught him to be wary. H e was afraid that the Elder Wand, recognizing his true owner, wouldn't work as intended, or worse, backfire on him. Giving Nagini the order to kill, indirectly would have. Why has the actor who plays Dumbledore changed? April 28, 2020 by archyde. HARRY POTTER 3 - British actor Richard Harris played Albus Dumbledore in the first two Harry Potter films. But following his death in 2002, Michael Gambon took over the role in The Prisoner of Azkaban. [Mis à jour le 28 avril 2020 à 20h45] It's a change of cast. The original Dumbledore, Richard Harris, sadly passed away from an aggressive form of Hodgkin's disease at age 72. Entertainment Weekly interviewed Chris Columbus (director of the first two Harry Potter films), who said Richard expected to play Dumbledore in the third film before he died. He did threaten to kill me if I recast [Dumbledore], Chris said Home Uncategorized why did dumbledore give harry the resurrection stone. why did dumbledore give harry the resurrection stone. June 7, 2021 Uncategorized No Comments.

Why did Draco cry when the bird died? He thought it was exciting to be a Death Eater at first, but then he realized what he was actually doing and he kinda fell apart. and broke into tears regretting his decision of becoming a death eater. Thats why Draco was crying there in the bathroom Also, Did Sirius Black die a virgin? Sirius, Snape and Peter died as virgins (most probably) with no heirs and their bloodlines died with them (unlike James and Remus).. Secondly, Who does Harry Potter lose his virginity to? Harrry Potter star Daniel Radcliffe confeses he lost his virginity when he reached the age of consent, 16, with a much older girlfriend Throughout the film, we're given no true hint to why Dumbledore won't fight Grindelwald himself. Even the Department of Magical Law Enforcement finds his lack of action suspect, going as far as to.

Video: Albus Dumbledore Harry Potter Wiki Fando

Harry Potter Image #755717 - Zerochan Anime Image Board

Why Did Snape Kill Dumbledore? - Fiction Horizo

  1. Why did Harry Potter not die in the Forbidden Forest? Voldemort unwittingly makes himself a Horcrux for Harry , although it might not be called that, by taking his blood earlier. In taking Harry's blood to regenerate himself, Voldemort ensures that Harry will not die if Voldemort kills him
  2. I have been thinking about this the last few times I have read OotP, and I have read a few other peopl's opinions as well. I think that if Dumbledore did not orchestrate Sirius' death, or help it along in any way, then he did nothig to stop it either. Why would Dumbledore want Sirius dead..
  3. HARRY POTTER was sent to live with The Dursleys after Voldemort murdered his parents and a popular new fan theory explains why he didn't go to his grandparents
  4. g headmaster. He frequently creates complex objects like sofa chairs out of thin air (or from less comfortable chairs).What did Dumbledore teach when he was a
  5. You have used me I have spied for you and lied for you, put myself in mortal danger for you. Everything was supposed to keep Lily Potter's son safe. Now you tell me you have been raising him like a pig for slaughter (chapter 33 p. 182-185). At the end of the day I see no reason why a reader should like Albus Dumbledore
  6. This all seems so obvious. Dumbledore sees Grindelwald, both as a young man and the older Dark Wizard, in the Mirror of Erised because he never stopped being in love with him and always hoped they could be together, which is why he was reluctant to fight him for years (he won't face him until 1945)

Why Harry Potter Movies Changed Dumbledore's Death (& Made

Why did they have to wear the locket? The locket contains a teeny tiny bit of Voldemort's soul. Harry, Hermione, and Ron have to wear the locket to keep it safe, but they can't wear it for too long, because otherwise their moods get really dark—especially Ron's. Read remaining answer here

Harry Potter Umschlag Pdf / Harry Potter Signs